October 14, 2011

The Pottermore Sorting Hat Dilema


Since the inception of Pottermore, many people have been faced with a very serious identity crisis. Where the book Sorting Hat usually takes your wishes into consideration, the Pottermore Sorting Hat does not. The Pottermore process involves asking the user several random questions about desired special abilities, greatest fears, life goals, and more. The user is encouraged to answer honestly in order to guarantee accurate results. The results, for some, have been less than welcome. Self-proclaimed Slytherins are getting sorted into Hufflepuff, Gryffindors are being named Slytherins, and this proud Puff has been placed in Ravenclaw. It's been a rough month for those of us who have been re-sorted.

After the initial hullabaloo died down, I took some time to interview several “mis-sorted” students in hopes of solving my own Puff vs. Claw predicament.

New York Harry Potter Meetup member, Hannah Taylor, a self-proclaimed Gryffindor, has been Pottermore sorted into Hufflepuff. While initially disappointed (I find that offensive), Hannah soon realized that she really did belong in the loyal house of the badger. "When I read my welcome letter... I realized that... I fit all of the traits of a typical Hufflepuff." Well, Hannah, welcome to my self-chosen house of hard-working, accepting, individuals. Of course, it may no longer be my house.


Hunger Games Fireside Chat Podcast co-host and supposed Ravenclaw Adam Spunberg also had a rude awakening. His welcome letter gleamed emerald and silver when he was sorted. "I thought I would [be horrified]," Adam says about his results, "but lately I've embraced my inner Slytherin. Having the "seeds of greatness" doesn't [always] mean dark magic and pure blood lines." Well said, Adam. I expect to see you sporting a Slytherin tie at the next TGTSNBN meetup. You and Jon Rosenthal can match. 

As I read more and more sorting stories, I found that most were pleased with their results, even if they weren't "correct". I was beginning to wonder if I should hang up my Hufflepuff robes and don a set in blue and bronze. Maybe I've been a Ravenclaw all along. After all, I like to read, I am studying to be a librarian, and I pride myself on being a unique individual. My nerdiness seemed to perfectly match Pottermore's description. Unwilling to make a decision, I turned to my good friend and fellow Pottermore Ravenclaw, Michèle Leclerc Turgeon.

Michèle, while sorted into Ravenclaw, considered herself to be a strong Slytherin. Despite an affinity toward Tonks, she is almost always decked in emerald and silver. When I asked her if she would stick with the snake, or switch to the eagle, her response was quick and sure: "[Of course] I will stay in [Slytherin]. I think I know myself better than a [seven] questions test, even if it was written by J.K. Rowling."

Ah. Michèle's succinct response left me no better off than I was before. Has J.K. Rowling seen into my soul and proclaimed me a clever and unique Ravenclaw? Or should I stubbornly remain a loyal and hardworking Hufflepuff? Sometimes the hat takes your wishes into consideration as it did in Harry's case. Sometimes, it does not, as it did with true Gryffindor, Neville Longbottom. Both circumstances ring true, and helped the student in question achieve greatness.

I guess in the end, it's really up to me.  The Sorting Hat is sadly fiction, and I am almost two decades late for my sorting anyway. So, while J.K. Rowling can help to guide me and others with a seven question algorithm on a website, the true results lie within me. After all, the whole reason Hogwarts house matters is that it gives readers a tinted lens through which to view the world, and live peacefully and productively amongst its people. 

For now, I remain, a proud Hufflepuff. While I pride myself on being different, well read, and smart, the traits I truly value are loyalty, hard work, and acceptance. And while I still plan on receiving my Master's Degree in Library Science, it will be through hard work and determination that I will get there. 

5 comments:

  1. Hi! I know what you are saying. I myself, have always, and I mean always, considered me a proud Ravenclaw, and every test I have taken has said so, except for the Pottermore test. According to the Sorting Hat, im a Hufflepuff. I have no issue with Hufflepuff, but its simply not my house. I know you understand, and as your friend Michele said, I continue to consider myself as a Ravenclaw.
    I also have a friend that has always known she was a Ravenclaw, who was sorted into Slytherin. She wanted to kill herself more or less.
    So, really, I think the whole Sorting Hat thing from Pottermore is utterly wrong, specially since it doesnt take into account what you want. I wrote that on a comment in Pottermore, but it couldnt let me publich it, because it said "but it should have...". I had to change it so that it said something like "its really great; I think it would be good if you considered...".
    Well, thank you for writing this. I needed to know more people were going through the same situation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I, a self clammed Puff (mostly cuz Tonks and I are one) was sorted into Gryffindor. I wasn't surprised, because I do have very strong Gryffindor qualities, but I also have strong Puff qualities, sometimes the two over lap for me. I'm so very hardworking as anyone who knows me can attest to. I would fight to the death for a friend making me both brave and loyal.

    I know the question that put me into Gryff it said, "you and three friends come to a bridge, a strange says you must fight him to pass. Do you fight on your own, al fight together, or pull straws" I said I would fight, but it said 3 friends, had it said 3 strangers my answer may have been fight together. I was answering it as someone being loyal but they took it as brave... which it may be but it was for my friends, So you see, I'm not sure it knew me. I'm not against either Gryff or Puff but I still dawn Puff colors and fell true and loyal to the house of the Badger, the house that had the most people fighting in the final battle at Hogwarts, the boy who gave his life to help happy in the Wizard Cup, the Girl who thought a man to love not only her but himself and the house some of my dearest friends are part of!

    In the end I think you though the questions are from JK, the answers are being taken by a computer and that can only go so far. I my still be a Gryff in the long run, but I could just as much be a Puff and there is so much that goes into the factors that I'm not sure Pottermore can handle.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Аn impгesѕiѵe shагe!

    I have just forwarded this onto a colleague who was conducting a littlе reseaгch оn this.
    And he actually ordereԁ me brеakfast due to the
    faсt thаt I disсovered it fοг him.
    .. lol. So allow me to rewoгd this.... Thanκѕ fоr the meal!
    ! But yеah, thanκs for spending timе to talk аbout thіs toрic
    here on youг web page.

    Also ѵisit my blog post ... DiamondLinks.net

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ηi there! Ι'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the fantastic work!

    Check out my web page - reputation management definition

    ReplyDelete
  5. I got sorted into Gryffindor, much to my disappointment. I am neither brave, nor loyal. Rather, I value wit, friendship, curiosity, love, and the truth. So I was hoping for either a Hufflepuff or a Ravenclaw.

    It's important to understand that not everyone wants to be a Gryffindor.

    ReplyDelete